Wednesday, July 25, 2007

Unfree Dominion

Canada muzzledWe have often noted in this space that Canada is ahead of the United States (and even parts of Europe) with its “hate speech” laws. Eventually we will catch up with our northern neighbor — Democrats in Congress are working on that right now — but for the time being, Canada leads the way in the illiberal suppression of free speech.

The latest instance of this progressive trend concerns the Free Dominion forum. A reader sent in a tip about this post (I couldn’t find a permalink; go to the main page and scroll down to look for it). It seems that the Powers That Be (Canadian Chapter) have discovered that Free Dominion has been posting doubleplus ungood thoughts, and must now be “investigated”:

Mark Fournier
Free Dominion
July 18, 2007

Human Rights attack on Free Dominion

We have been waiting for six and a half years and the day has finally arrived, somebody is going to try to silence Free Dominion using the Canadian Human Rights Commission.

Moments ago we found this in Free Dominion’s mailbox:

July 16, 2007
File 2006057
Ms. Connie Wilkins
c/o Free Dominion
2033 Unity Rd.
Kingston, ON
K0H 1M0

Dear Ms. Wilkins:

I am the investigator designated under Part III of the Canadian Human Rights Act to investigate the complaint of Ms. [name omitted at this time] against Free Dominion. As the investigator, it is my responsibility to gather the evidence in relation to the complainant’s allegations and, once the investigation is complete, to report on my findings to the Members of the Commission.

The report will include a recommendation for the disposition of the complaint. I can recommend that a conciliator be appointed, if the evidence supports the allegations in the complaint, or that the complaint be dismissed, if the allegations are not supported by the evidence. I can also recommend to the Commission that a settlement be approved if the parties reach an agreement during the course of the investigation.

I am currently awaiting your full response to the allegations which is due on 18 July 2007.
- - - - - - - - - -
I would like to draw your attention to section 48 of the Canadian Human Rights Act which allows the parties to settle a complaint in the course of investigation. I would be pleased to discuss the possibility of a settlement with you or your representative at any time.

You can reach me at the address and telephone number indicated at the bottom of the first page of this letter. My direct line is 999-999-9999 and my email address is Please note that there are security and confidentiality risks in sending information by email.

Yours Sincerely,

Officer’s Name

*   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *

This looks real. It appears to be written on official Canadian Human Rights Commission letterhead stationary.

Other than the last name of the complainant, this doesn’t tell us much. It doesn’t say what the complaint is about or anything else. Notice also that Connie was supposed to have responded to it by July 18, 2007, which is today. It was a fluke that we even checked the mailbox before we came home.

Somebody has likely decided that because they can’t defeat some argument presented by someone at Free Dominion they will instead try to silence the whole site. It isn’t going to work.

We will be keeping everybody posted on each development as it occurs. If this persecution actually proceeds it will not be under the cover of darkness, we will keep a very bright light shining every step of the way.

I promise.

Hat tip: STN.


rickl said...

I am currently awaiting your full response to the allegations which is due on 18 July 2007.

The first reply that springs to mind is "NUTS!"

Zerosumgame said...

Can't they get around these "hate speech" laws by putting the server in the USA?

A lot of European blogs do that.

Profitsbeard said...

The only answer to such suppression of Free Speech (as with the Canadian example) is to tell them to Go to hell -rather than trying to create one on Earth.

And take the consequences of the defiance.

And make it a cause celebre.

Or this nanny-statism will erode our freedoms quietly, softly, smilingly, gently away.

Do not go gentle into that bad night.

Paul Weston said...

I find that when confronted by a BBC demand for licence payment, a short note entitled f**k off or take me court, I have dossiers on your bias, works a treat.

I would reccomend a similar respone in this instance.

Vol-in-Law said...

STN here - just a note that I came across this story in BNA News, a daily roundup of Internet-law news for legal experts (whose author is Canadian), and it linked to a newspaper article about it - unfortunately I deleted the link; but it's good this made the mainstream media.

Flanders Fields said...

Suggest checking with the Brussels Journal. Paul Belien has been through similar actions in the European theater of the leftist assault against freedom. We do need to stop these. It will only become more problematic as time goes on and staffs and budgets get increased.

People need to understand this.

genslub3 said...

Flanders hence why I and a swarm of others have posted it on my blog.

I'm risking arrest fines etc. However if one person breaks a law and everyone puts their heads down they have kept us in line.

If everyone says Look officer I'm doing it too, there isn't much the thought police can do.

My threads on [about] the Fatwah here.