Monday, November 17, 2008

Reverting to Christianity in Kosovo

The Coming Balkan CaliphateChristopher Deliso, the author of The Coming Balkan Caliphate: The Threat of Radical Islam to Europe and the West, wrote a fascinating article last month at Balkan Analysis about the changes that are occurring in the newly independent state of Kosovo.

The situation is complex. Yes, there is still the threat of radical Islam, which established and strengthened a network of mujahideen after 1999 under the UN protectorate. The radicals channeled Saudi money into the building of mosques and used financial incentives to convert Albanian Kosovars to their cause.

Yes, organized crime maintains a substantial presence, running drugs, trafficking in prostitutes, and selling weapons throughout much of Europe from their base in Kosovo.

But outside the rarefied circles of Wahhabist zeal in the KLA and affiliated groups, the hold of Islam on Kosovo is not that strong. In his article Mr. Deliso analyzes the reasons for this, paying particular attention to the history of forced conversions that were inflicted upon the local Catholic population by their Turkish overlords in the Balkan borderlands of the Ottoman empire.

Much of the population has a deep collective memory of its Christian past, and retains a cultural attachment to the Catholic church. Even though Islam is in the ascendant with the independence of Kosovo, many Kosovar Muslims are re-converting to Christianity.

Here are some excerpts from Mr. Deliso’s article:

Lost in Conversion?
By Christopher Deliso

When Kosovo’s Albanians celebrated the major Muslim holiday of Bajram, at the end of September, more than a few worshippers were conspicuous for their absence.

A trickle of media articles over the past few months have dealt with the issue of religion in Kosovo from a relatively unreported angle: the curious phenomenon of conversion. Apparently, Albanians in this Muslim-majority statelet have been increasingly ‘returning’ to the Catholic religion, which their ancestors had forsaken centuries ago.

This story is interesting and relevant in its own right, but has become particularly revealing in light of the way it has been developed in the media, something that raises another set of issues. Whereas early reports of a new trend towards conversion mentioned the fact that Albanians had been Christians before the Ottomans arrived in the 14th century, and converted thereafter, only recently have reports begun adding an element of victimology to the narrative.

For example, a Sept. 28 Reuters report that took the pulse of recently reborn Catholics in Kosovo claimed that ‘…the majority of ethnic Albanians were forcibly converted to Islam, mostly through the imposition of high taxes on Catholics, when the Ottoman Empire ruled the Balkans.’ This almost seems to imply that other Christians were threatened with taxation by the Turks, but did not convert. It also ignores that in several places at different times, Christians seeking to convert were actually prevented from doing so because the Ottomans prudently sought they would lose a local tax base for relatively little in return.

Reuters’ description of ‘forcible conversion’ as something to be equated with desire for social advancement is a strange one. The real things that were forcible for the Ottomans were the forced kidnappings of young Christian men and women for the janissary corps and harems of Constantinople. Although there were far worse things to be suffered than paying high taxes by remaining Christian under the Turks, these were left out. In backwards hinterlands of the empire, as in Kosovo and Bosnia, the local Muslim lords were known for being especially pernicious towards those who did not desert their religion.
- - - - - - - - -
Although this disparity led to simmering resentments which had long-term influence, as pointed out by former NSA officer John Schindler in the Bosnian context, the article does not consider how inter-ethnic problems in Kosovo today might perhaps have roots in this phenomenon. Schindler notes that it was particularly in border hinterlands of the empire such as Bosnia and Kosovo that the rule of the Turks and converted local lords allegiant to them was especially vicious. The Orthodox Christian Serbs clung to their religion — and suffered under the rule of those who found it expedient to change their own. Understanding the context of local opinions today requires an appreciation of this former relationship.

Within the Albanian community itself, how is the conversion issue playing out? The Kosovars interviewed by Reuters tended to take the ‘crypto-Christian’ route, by which they claimed that their forefathers only pretended to be Muslims: “…for centuries, many remembered their Christian roots and lived as what they call ‘Catholics in hiding.’ Some, nearly a century after the Ottomans left the Balkans, now see the chance to reveal their true beliefs.”


In Pristina, inside a small Catholic church, the caretaker informed us that some 21 people had come in the previous three months to re-embrace the faith; more were expected to emerge. As the Reuters article points out, a large Catholic cathedral is being built here, much to the displeasure of Muslim leaders. The article quotes the head of the Kosovo Islamic community, Mufti Naim Ternava, who is opposed to the building of the new cathedral at the heart of Pristina, as criticizing rural church-building as well: “…no human brain can understand how a church should be build in the middle of 13 Muslim villages,” he said.

Supporters of Kosovar Catholicism inevitably point to Mother Teresa, born in nearby Skopje, who has became the symbol of Albanian Christianity far and wide, a cultural process that has brought criticism from Muslim groups in Albania itself. Recent examples of some of these animosities are discussed in my book The Coming Balkan Caliphate: The Threat of Radical Islam to Europe and the West (Praeger Security International, 2007), in which I maintain that, in Kosovo the end of the nationalist question (i.e., with the achievement of statehood) is the beginning of the religious one.

The religious question in Kosovo is this: how Muslim are you if your ancestors were forcibly converted to Islam more than half a millennium ago? By now your family’s connection to Christianity should have faded into nothing — if normal historical processes were at work, that is. But the Balkans are not normal, and half a millennium is but a moment in the local chronology of events. The enmities that drove Gavriel Princip to assassinate Archduke Franz Ferdinand in June 1914 are still seething, virtually unchanged almost a century later.

And the deeds of the Ottomans have not been forgotten.

However, the new fundamentalist forces operating in Kosovo are Arab, rather than Turkish, in origin:

The arrival of fundamentalist Islam was the result of strong cross-border logistical networks, ‘safe houses’ and propaganda channels blossomed after August 1999, when the United Nations began administering Kosovo following NATO’s bombing campaign. At that point, Wahhabi proselytizers from the Arab world descended on Kosovo in force. They arrived chiefly through humanitarian and cultural organizations, many under the umbrella of the Saudi Joint Committee for the Relief of Kosovo and Chechnya and the Saudi Red Crescent Society. According to numerous former UN officials in Kosovo, however, these ostensibly humanitarian groups spent most of their time building mosques, proselytizing, and paying Albanians monthly stipends to dress and act according to conservative Wahhabi mores.

Although American pressure led to some charities being uprooted following 9/11, many remained durable. A prime example is the RIHS. In 2003, leaked UN police reports and photos indicated the ongoing activities in Kosovo of a Kuwaiti worldwide charity, the Revival of Islamic Heritage Society (RIHS), which had been blacklisted by the Bush administration in Pakistan and Afghanistan for having ties to al Qaeda early the year before, and which had, in Albania during the early 1990s, been used to shield terrorists belonging to Egyptian Islamic Jihad.

At the same time in war-torn Bosnia, the RIHS was creating radical youth groups to disseminate jihad propaganda, catering to war orphans and other impressionable young people. The fact that the RIHS had, despite also being implicated in 500 simultaneous bombings in Bangladesh in August 2005, been allowed to continue its activities in Albania, Kosovo and Bosnia came to light in June 2006, with a Bosnian prosecutor’s investigation into some 14 million euros in RIHS funds that mysteriously could not be accounted for. Yet despite reportedly changing its addresses and information frequently in Bosnia, the organization still apparently works freely in the world’s newest independent state, Kosovo.

Along with building hundreds of new mosques, disseminating Islamist propaganda and inculcating it into the young, the proponents of Wahhabism sought to spread their tentacles by establishing an Islamic banking system in rural areas historically prone to isolationism and radicalism. One such charity, Islamic Relief, had already by September 2004 provided 500 loans to impoverished Kosovar farmers and small businessmen, according to “Islamic principles.” In poor areas where the West has shown little interest in supplying aid, the foreign Islamists have been happy to do so.

A further concern here is the convergence of terrorism with organized crime in Kosovo, particularly the global trafficking in human beings, narcotics and weapons. Kosovo has served as a terrorist transfer zone, in which Wahhabi-run villages and mosques became safe harbor for foreigners wanted in Western Europe or in their own countries for terrorism links.

The direct connection between terrorism and narcotics trafficking has been revealed on numerous occasions, as with Norway’s September 2006 arrest of al Qaeda operative Arfan Qadeer Bhatti. He and his accomplices were planning attacks on the US and Israeli embassies in Oslo; according to Norwegian news reports, they even planned to behead the Israeli ambassador. This Pakistani terrorist had connections with a Kosovo Albanian drug lord and even visited Pristina and Pec, a small town in western Kosovo, where he could administer to one of Kosovo’s largest Wahhabi flocks.

Nevertheless, radical Islam has failed to catch on with the masses, and the Vatican — led by a Europe-focused German Pope — is eager to build on its success in spreading Catholicism more widely.

So how is it that Catholicism has been gaining ground, given the enormous organizational and financial advantages enjoyed by the Saudis?

An Italian journalist specializing in security issues who has conducted investigations in Kosovo, Paola Casoli, stated for that the Catholic church’s “[ecumenical] concept and the huge network of relations due to the Vatican’s foreign politics [means] the presence of the Vatican through its representatives on the ground is obvious enough.”

According to Casoli, the church’s different approach to dealing with local Albanians also accounts for its success. “Add also the presence of ecclesiastic or ecclesiastic-related organizations, such as Caritas,” she says, citing a young Catholic Albanian, who maintained that the church “remained close to people’s needs, instead of [the Muslim groups that were] building mosques in every village.”

Casoli also sees the success of Catholicism in Kosovo these days as partially linguistic in nature. “Islamism imposes Arabic when addressing God and praying to Him,” she says, “whereas Albanians speak Albanian and not Arabic as their mother tongue,” and thus prefer this form of worship.


Clearly, matters of religious belief are still being shaped by divergent historical interpretation in the Balkans today. If it were only a question of spirited debate, however, things would be relatively tame. However, a series of low-profile incidents, most unreported, continue. They include defacement of monuments in the north and churches in the Greek-minority south. One of the most interesting questions for the future is the extent to which a Catholic-Muslim divide in Kosovo will be felt in neighboring Albania, a country with strong social and historical connections.

There’s much more to be found at Balkan Analysis, and I recommend the entire article.

Hat tip: C. Cantoni.


Anonymous said...

Fascinating... for those who don't know, I have an interest in the Balkans. Thanks for posting this, Baron--it's very, very interesting.

Fellow Peacekeeper said...

I have to be a cynic here - the Albanians are migrating towards a religion that is more compatible with the bandit lifestyle. Drink, whore, steal and be merry, and Sunday God will forgive you. Don't underestimate the impact of Italian TV and the ubiquitous South American soap operas.

Cole's Blog said...

Looking forward to digesting this when I have the time this evening, but it looks like an excellent post.


Afonso Henriques said...


However, I don't think they will have a tenth of the success Budhism has here (which is almost none).
Another interesting thing would be to find the origins of the Albanians... They are just the Christians who converted cowardly to islam, in my opinion...
The Balkans are indeed a very fascinating place.

Just a side note:
"Casoli also sees the success of Catholicism in Kosovo these days as partially linguistic in nature. “Islamism imposes Arabic when addressing God and praying to Him,” she says, “whereas Albanians speak Albanian and not Arabic as their mother tongue,” and thus prefer this form of worship."

Great argument! Really, what an argument! It is really difficult for the Catholic Church to go down even further.

If they continue to do this, and converting Eastern Europeans, perhaps the Orthodox would start to send missionaries to the West... It apears the Catholic Church has abandoned European Civilisation.

akhter said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Baron Bodissey said...

akhter --

That's WAY too long for a comment here. That constitutes comment abuse.

Put it in your blog and leave a link here.

Czechmade said...

Albanians played a game with Osmans, pretending to be this or that acc. to the situation. Living in less accessible remote areas, they could do this quasi unpunished.

Remember that Monsieur Atta Tuerk was half Albanian and half Macedonian (mom). If you take seriously the muslim concept, Atta Tuerk was an Albanian...

Now in the triangle of choices - the orthodox church is evil/Serbian (if you live in Kosovo) for them, catholic faith being the ticket in the West, islam the ticket to ME. The tribal society might prefer islam, but is it getting stronger or weaker? Kosovo is not exactly Albania.

Serbia is much more free, do they embrace orthodox church like Kosturica - those who live in Serbia?