Monday, May 19, 2008

Michael Moore Can’t Distinguish between War Porn and Nobility

The following is just a part of Michael Yon’s post on the latest episode of the sleazy conduct of Michael Moore:

Many readers have complained that Michael Moore, in the conduct of his latest crusade against whatever he is against this month, has illegally used one of my photos on the banner of his website. Mr. Moore is not the first to have done so, and my readers can get pretty upset when it happens.

My lawyer has demanded that Mr. Moore take it down.

I usually freely grant use of my work to truthful, peaceful, non-commercial, non-political outlets. For instance, a church group wanted to use one of my photos for their congregation. I was honored and gave it to them freely. On another occasion, a peaceful, non-profit Islamic organization wanted to use the same photo that Michael Moore has infringed upon (Major Mark Bieger cradling a little girl named Farah), and I was honored to contribute to their peaceful cause.

For any of you not familiar with the iconic image of Farah dying in the Major’s arms as he runs for medical help, click on Yon’s site to see how Michael Moore has filched it that image and used it for political purposes. You’ll find it on the lower right hand side of the banner Moore has on his website. Yon has a screen cap.

To see the framed photograph of this image, which Yon has titled “Strength and Compassion” (the definition of a mensch, by the way) click here. It is also the picture on Yon’s book, Moment of Truth, available on Amazon, but if you buy it through his website, you can get an autographed copy. I’ve read the book and will be reviewing it eventually. Incidentally, the full title is actually Moment of Truth in Iraq: How a New ‘Greatest Generation’ of American Soldiers is Turning Defeat and Disaster into Victory and Hope -- just in case you wondered what side he was on.

One of the nice things about the book is that he treats the British soldiers with respect.

Michael Yon has lived through this so far. I hope he makes it back.

He says:

I’ve seen grandmothers use my work in technically illegal ways, but since they’re not a big company, they probably have no idea about copyright, and usually use the work in tasteful, appropriate ways, I just smile and say, “Go ahead, Ma’am.”

But frequently, big companies and individuals who are knowledgeable of copyright laws filch my work and use it in ways that many readers consider partisan, highly political or incendiary. When this happens, I usually go after the infringer, and so do my readers.

Now here’s Michael Moore, the latest infringer, using my work for his own crude political purposes.
- - - - - - - - -
I recall some years ago watching one of his movies in Paris, and thinking how sad it was that an American would make propaganda so flagrant that it seemed pornographic. It was sad but at the same time uplifting, because Mr. Moore was able to exercise his right to free speech, rights that should never be infringed upon.

Mr. Moore is influential, rich, and could likely intimidate most photographers. But I ask my readers to please leave him be. Attacking him likely will be counterproductive. I know how to fight, and though I would fight for Mr. Moore’s right to free expression, I will fight against him if he steals my work and uses it in an inflammatory fashion.

The use Mr. Moore made of Farah’s dying moments and the desperation in the bowed head of the Major, fighting to keep her alive, is definitely inflammatory and ugly, in that special Michael Moore degradation of nobility in suffering.

Mr. Yon continues:

It’s got nothing to do with the fact that Michael Moore is anti-war (he’s not just against the Iraq War, but he was also against the war in Afghanistan). I respect Moore’s opposition to the Iraq War; I might even agree with him on some particulars. But I object to the tone of many of his arguments, especially the manner in which he uses my work to further his causes. As I said above, sometimes it seems pornographic. That’s a strong word, so I’ll explain.

Justice Potter Stewart once defined pornography by saying, “I know it when I see it.” Pornography and propaganda are closely related, as they are both cynical attempts at manipulation, rooted in a lack of respect for humanity. War Porn is one of the more disturbing developments in the new media, as people on both sides of the Iraq War get their kicks watching video images of death and destruction - as long as it’s their opponents who get killed.

Whether it’s an Al Qaeda cell-phone video of an IED attack or the grisly footage of a Coalition air strike, War Porn is degrading and incendiary. Of course, some footage is newsworthy and informative and the public deserves to see it. There is also great value to soldiers in watching footage for training purposes and to better understand battlefields and weapons.

But at some point, especially when the material is used to make political points, images of combat can cross the line into pornography. People die in war, but we must never forget that each casualty is a human being, even people as deserving of death as Al Qaeda. Denying our opponents’ humanity, we lose a little of our own.

When someone’s grandmother disseminates the photo of Major Beiger cradling a dying girl in his arms, I allow the usage because I feel she is trying to share the human tragedy.

When Michael Moore puts that same photo on his web site, alongside images of George Bush, John McCain and Hillary Clinton, the clear implication is that Farah’s death is their fault. That is a misrepresentation of the facts on the ground, as well as the story of the photo.

Farah was killed by a suicide car bomb in Mosul on May 2, 2005. Major Bieger and other soldiers literally risked their own lives to save many children and adults that day, but Farah didn’t make it.

Michael Moore apparently does not understand - or refuses to acknowledge - the moral distinction between a man who would murder innocent people, and a man who would sacrifice himself to save them. The photo, as I took it, is the truth, but Moore uses it - illegally - to convey falsehoods. His mind is that of a political propagandist who sees Farah’s death not as a human tragedy, but a tool.

We need to know the truth about the wars we are currently fighting. That’s why I went to Iraq in the first place. Sometimes the difference between War Porn and the truth can be subtle, ambiguous, even subjective. But I know it when I see it. And if Michael Moore learned to respect not just my work, but other aspects of the truth, not to mention respecting his audience’s intelligence, he would better serve his own cause.

There is much more in his post, I recommend that you read it through by using the link provided.

In the meantime, may Michael Moore get all that he deserves in life, in abundance.


Findalis said...

Mr. Yon is a gentleman. He shows compassion in his work. Mr. Moore is a prostitute. He cares only about his ego.

In a fight like this, I will always root for the gentleman.

babs said...

It really is a shame that such a beautiful photo; full of caring, compassion, heart ache and love would be hijacked by someone with such a crass opinion of human suffering.

Henrik R Clausen said...

I've frequently wondered what to do about rabid anti-everything persons like Mr. Moore.

Mr. Yon shows the way: trip them up when they overstep themselves. Gently, just using the law, nothing excessive. He holds the copyright to his images and has the right to prevent any use he doesn't like.

Civil society in action, too.

no2liberals said...

"People die in war, but we must never forget that each casualty is a human being, even people as deserving of death as Al Qaeda. Denying our opponents’ humanity, we lose a little of our own."
Words to live by, from a true warrior philosopher. It's Yon's courage and humanity that I have found so appealing and compelling for all these years.

Moore could never respect his audiences intelligence, or any other aspect of their beings.
He doesn't respect himself.
And now this enemy propagandist is making a sequel to Fahrenhype 911.

EW1(SG) said...

The very first blopost that I wrote was inspired by Michael Yon's photo of Major Bieger comforting Farah, it may be found here.

At the time that he published the photo, I requested permission to use it noncommercially (on my blog) but was politely rebuffed by his attorneys firm.
(Although there was some room for linking to it in a manner consistent with Mr. Yon's wishes, as conveyed in our correspondence.)

In any case, it remains an extremely powerful image, one that never fails to bring tears to my eyes and remind me that there really is evil in the world that need be fought.

      "-- just in case you wondered what side he was on."

Although Michael Yon displays incredible objectivity in his reporting, there is never any doubt about what "side" he is on: he is on our soldier's side first and foremost (so much so as to pick up a weapon in battle to illicitly protect them), and ultimately on the side of good versus evil.

(Note: The photo link at my website is purposely not up to date.)